The Advocate – Company officials reject explanation of sinkhole’s formation
By David J. Mitchell
The sidewall of a Texas Brine Co. LLC salt cavern inside the Napoleonville Dome was dissolved through the dome’s outer edge, bringing the cavern into contact with surrounding sediment layers outside the dome before the cavern failed, an LSU geologist said Friday.
The assessment by Jeffrey Nunn, Ernest and Alice Neal professor of geology and geophysics and Pereboom professor of science, was a step beyond what other officials and scientists working on the sinkhole response have presented in public meetings and appeared to more closely lay the blame with Texas Brine, which mined the cavern by dissolving the salt.
Nunn spoke about factors leading to the sinkhole Friday during a luncheon talk at Mike Anderson’s restaurant to the Baton Rouge Geological Society. . . . .
http://theadvocate.com/home/4685215-125/geologist-details-failure-factors
“What this indicates is that the bottom part of this abandoned cavern completely dissolved away the salt and the cavern was in direct contact with whatever formation is in the area,” Nunn said.
The seismic data indicates that the western side of the dome has an overhang, or bulge on its upper side, where the salt edge goes out but then curves back inward and possibly intersects with the Texas Brine cavity, exposing it to outer sediments.
AND –
Nunn told geologists Friday that one of the scientists’ worst-case fears is that the salt dome could continue to break up from its western edge and threaten other underground caverns.
“We can state that during the 25-plus years of the life of this cavern, there was never any indication of a loss of integrity of the cavern,” Sonny Cranch, Texas Brine spokesman, said.
Really?? http://tinyurl.com/9t9sbjc
2+2=5
he is such an idiot
There’s a first time for everything! The OXY-3 cavern was too close to the outer edge of the Napoleanville salt dome. To repeat, Texas Brine knew that the cavern was compromised when they pulled out in 2011. They lost precious time to rectify this problem because they failed to act quickly enough. Texas Brine continues to lose time because they continue to deny, deny, deny, deny the facts presented by educated, degreed, professionals. You snooze, you lose! Texas Brine thinks they can fool the residents into believing that they are not in the wrong.
‘…Nunn, who has been speaking with a group of scientists working closely on the sinkhole, pointed to 3-D seismic imagery of the salt dome from 2007 to make his case.
“What this indicates is that the bottom part of this abandoned cavern completely dissolved away the salt and the cavern was in direct contact with whatever formation is in the area,” Nunn said. …’
I may be reading the above segment of the article wrong, but it seems to indicate to my mind that the damage was already done back in 2007, not last year. And that the information about a possible collapse has been around longer than we have been led to believe.
After all, unless the 2007 3D image actually showed evidence of the cavern being compromised, it would be very foolhardy of any scientist to use it in any claim that it had happened.
Could it be that Nunn was using the 2007 imagery as a reference point against current imagery? *If* the 2007 imagery shows different results than current imagery, then it could reveal the nature and extent of any changes between 2007 & 2012.
I’d like to see that imagery.
I wonder if it stashed somewhere on an LSU website . . .
Perhaps somebody could contact Professor Jeffrey Nunn and ask him if he could possibly make a copy of the images available ??
Ther has not been any new 3D imaging yet. They say 3-4 months,possibly.
I suspect LSU has its own stuff.
I think they have seismic monitors not viewable by the public there. But just me … no proof.
Then we can thank Nunn for being humane enough to out TB on the “integrity” issue!
Many people have copies of the letter that TB sent DNR in Jan 2011, in which they state loss of integrity during the life of the cavern is under review.
he wants HIS hands clean by leaving an honest paper trail … even though he’s surrounded by crooks!
The cdopy of those documents are online. Just google “letter to DNR from Texas Brine”. It’s the Advocate article by David Mitchell. Clickable links.
http://theadvocate.com/home/3580029-125/dome-issues-kept-quiet
Plus, they are easily found just swearching google.
that means ‘swearing-at & searching Google’ 🙂